“Misery” was written by John Lennon and Paul McCartney, and the two of them share the lead vocal. It was written for Helen Shapiro to record; she turned it down, and Kenny Lynch recorded it instead (Lewisohn p.8).

Why is the piano on Misery recorded at half speed?

George Harrison could not play the descending guitar figure smoothly, so George Martin asked him to leave it out and had a take of live rhythm and vocal recorded with the Twin-Track machine running at 30ips instead of the standard 15ips. At the overdub he played the line on piano at half speed and an octave lower; back at full speed it returns at the right pitch and tempo with a timbre no piano produces naturally. It is the only track on the album made this way (Kehew and Ryan pp.362, 368).

Was Geoff Emerick on the Misery session?

Yes. The tape operator at the 20 February 1963 piano overdub was Geoff Emerick, and both primary sources record it as his first appearance on a Beatles session. Stuart Eltham engineered that date rather than Norman Smith (Lewisohn p.28; Kehew and Ryan p.362).

Misery

(Lennon/McCartney)

Quick Facts

Composer	John & Paul
Lead Vocal	John & Paul
Recorded	Feb 1963
Length	1:48
Key	C
Noted Takes	16
Producer	George Martin
Engineer	Norman Smith

Originally released on

Please Please Me (LP)

The Beatles (No. 1) (EP)

Parlophone — PMC 1202 / PCS 3042

Find on Amazon

Page status: In review

Story Section status: Outdated

“Misery” is a song by the English rock band the Beatles from their 1963 debut album Please Please Me. It was co-written by John and Paul. According to John, “It was kind of a John song more than a Paul song, but it was written together.” Paul was to say: “I don’t think either one of us dominated on that one, it was just a hacking job.”

Misery is a song by The Beatles, written by Lennon–McCartney and led on vocal by John & Paul. Originally offered to Helen Shapiro who turned it down; George Martin overdubs piano. Within the catalogue, its heartbreak thread connects it to Anna (Go to Him); its early thread connects it to There’s a Place. Misery, with its bluesy minor-key framework and John’s lead vocal, was among the earliest professional compositions written specifically for another artist—intended as an audition piece for a female vocalist on George Martin’s label.¹

The session work falls within the band’s Beatlemania (1962–1964) period, first recorded 11 February 1963 during the Please Please Me album marathon at EMI Studios, Abbey Road. George Martin produced; Norman Smith engineered. The song was captured in eleven takes on the marathon day, with five additional superimposition takes recorded on 20 February when George Martin overdubbed his piano part. Mono and stereo mixing from take 16 took place on 25 February 1963.¹

What’s distinctive

At 1:48 it is one of the shortest things the Beatles ever released, and the only track on Please Please Me built with half-speed overdubbing. George could not play the descending figure that answers the second line of each verse cleanly, so the part was handed to a piano running at half the tape speed and an octave down — a fix that became a technique, and one the group reached for again a year later. Written to order for Helen Shapiro, who declined it. Take count: 16, the highest numbered take across two sessions.

Recording

‘Misery’ was written to order. John and Paul wrote it for Helen Shapiro to record and she turned it down; in the end Kenny Lynch was the one who released it. Nothing in the mounted record says the pair thought much of it afterwards, and Paul’s own account of the song is affectionate rather than proud — the lyric he remembers is the downbeat one about the world treating him bad.¹
The band taped it on 11 February 1963, in the 2.30–6.00pm session of the day that produced ten of the fourteen tracks on Please Please Me. Eleven takes were recorded, and John and Paul shared the lead vocal. The album day ran across three blocks in Studio Two, 10.00am to 10.45pm, under George Martin with Norman Smith at the desk and Richard Langham as tape operator — 585 minutes that the session log makes look far more orderly than they can have felt.¹
The one thing that would not come right was a guitar part. George could not smoothly play the descending figure that follows the line about remembering all the little things we’ve done, and after enough attempts George Martin asked him to leave it out of the take altogether. That decision is the reason this page has anything technical on it at all: everything that follows is the workaround.²
Martin then asked for a take of live rhythm and vocal to be recorded with the Twin-Track machine running at 30 ips — double the studio’s standard 15 ips. Running the tape twice as fast is the setup for a half-speed overdub: play the tape back at 15 ips and the whole performance drops an octave and halves in tempo, which turns an unplayable line into a playable one.²
Every one of the initial takes went down simultaneously to both Twin-Track and Delta-Mono. On the album day that combination carried a meaning: material intended for later overdubbing went to Twin-Track only, while anything the control room considered finished went to both. ‘Misery’ being on both tapes is the strongest surviving evidence that nobody expected to add anything to it — had the guitar line come off, there would have been no piano.²
The overdub happened nine days later, on 20 February, in Studio One, and the Beatles were not there. George Martin did all the work himself, adding piano to ‘Misery’ and first celeste and then piano to ‘Baby It’s You’. Stuart Eltham engineered rather than Norman Smith, and the tape operator was Geoff Emerick — his first appearance on a Beatles session, three years before he took over the balance chair.^1,2
With both Twin-Track machines running at 15 ips, Martin performed the descending line at half speed and an octave lower, overdubbing the piano onto the vocal track. Returned to 30 ips it plays back at the intended pitch and tempo, but with an attack and decay that no piano produces in real time — brighter, faster to speak, and slightly unreal against the guitars.²
The piano was also sent to the echo chamber during the overdub, and the chamber return was recorded to tape at the same time rather than added later. It therefore went through the same speed change as the piano itself, which is why the reverb on that one instrument sits higher and moves faster than the ambience around everything else on the track.²
Mono and stereo masters were made on 25 February 1963 in the Studio One control room, from take 16. The Beatles were not present for that either, and the album followed on 22 March.¹

Equipment

Studio	EMI Studios, Abbey Road — Studio Two (11 Feb 1963 recording); Studio One (20 Feb overdub; 25 Feb mixing)
Tape machine	Twin-Track 1/4″ EMI BTR3 (tracking, and both machines for the half-speed superimposition); Delta-Mono alongside the Twin-Track on the initial takes; mixdown 1/4″ EMI BTR2 (mono) and 1/4″ EMI BTR3 (stereo)
Console	REDD.37 (the 1963 desk in both Studio One and Studio Two)
Microphones	1963 standard set: Neumann U48 on vocals; Neumann U47 or U48 on piano and acoustic guitar; Neumann U47, U48 or KM-54 on electric guitar; STC 4038 drum overheads; STC 4033-A on bass, and STC 4033-A or AKG D19 on bass drum
Outboard / effects	EMI RS124 compressor, EMI RS114 limiter, RS127 Presence Box; echo chamber, recorded to tape with the piano rather than added at the mix
Tape speed	30 ips for the basic take, against the house standard 15 ips; both Twin-Track machines dropped to 15 ips for the piano overdub

Recording Timeline

11 February 1963 (Mon) — takes 1–11, Studio Two, 2.30–6.00pm — P: George Martin. E: Norman Smith. 2E: Richard Langham. The afternoon block of the album day; the morning had run 10.00am–1.00pm and the evening would run 7.30–10.45pm. John and Paul shared the lead vocal, and the takes went down to Twin-Track and Delta-Mono at the same time. Somewhere in these eleven takes George gave up on the descending figure at Martin’s request, and the producer asked for a take of live rhythm and vocal to be captured with the Twin-Track machine running at 30 ips rather than the standard 15 — a decision made on the floor, mid-session, to solve a problem that could not be solved by another take.^1,2
20 February 1963 (Wed) — superimposition takes 12–16, Studio One, 10.30am–1.00pm — P: George Martin. E: Stuart Eltham. 2E: Geoff Emerick. The Beatles were not present; Martin did all the work, adding piano to ‘Misery’ and first celeste and then piano to ‘Baby It’s You’ (superimposition takes 4–6 on that song). Both Twin-Track machines ran at 15 ips, so the 30 ips performance played back an octave down at half tempo and Martin could pick out the descending line at a speed it was possible to play. The piano was routed to the echo chamber and the chamber return committed to tape in the same pass. Stuart Eltham was Martin’s regular engineer on his non-pop work, which is why an unattended piano overdub drew him rather than Norman Smith.^1,2
25 February 1963 (Mon) — mono and stereo mixing, Studio One control room — P: George Martin. E: Norman Smith. Mono and stereo masters were made from take 16, in the sitting that mixed most of the album; the Beatles were not present. Playing the tape at its intended speed for the mixdown is what returns the piano and its chamber return to correct pitch, so the mix session is also the first time anyone heard the overdub as the record would carry it.¹
22 March 1963 (Fri) — Please Please Me issued — ‘Misery’ sits second on side one, directly after ‘I Saw Her Standing There’. The LP went to the top of the UK chart in May and stayed there for thirty weeks. Eight months later the song was pulled for an EP, The Beatles (No 1), where it again ran second, behind the same album opener.¹

‘Misery’ was for Helen Shapiro, and she turned it down. [Makes mock pain noise.] It may not have been that successful for her because it’s a rather downbeat song, “world’s treating me bad, misery”.— Paul McCartney¹

Studio Notes

The only half-speed overdub of 1963. Recording at one speed and overdubbing at another would become a routine part of the Beatles’ method within a few years, but in 1963 it was used on exactly one track, and this is it. That matters for how the record sounds: the piano is not merely a piano brought up in the mix, it is an instrument that never played at the pitch or tempo you hear. The attack arrives faster than a hammer on a string can manage and the decay shortens with it, which is why the figure reads as slightly synthetic against guitars recorded normally in the same room.²
The technique was a repair, not an idea. The sequence in the control room ran problem, concession, workaround: George could not play the descending figure cleanly; Martin asked him to stop playing it; and only then did the producer call for the 30 ips take. It is worth stating plainly because the finished record invites the opposite reading — the piano sounds like a deliberate colour, and it was originally a guitar part nobody could land.²
The tape format is the evidence. Through the album day, songs still expecting an overdub were committed to Twin-Track alone, while songs the control room regarded as finished went to Twin-Track and Delta-Mono together. All the initial takes of ‘Misery’ went to both. The inference is unusually clean for a 1963 session: had the guitar part come off, the song would have been considered complete and no piano would ever have been added. The tape boxes record an intention that the finished record contradicts.²
Why it could not simply be re-cut. The band had engagements every day for nearly three weeks after the all-day session, so there was no window in which George could come back and try the line again. The overdub was not chosen over a retake; it was chosen instead of a retake that the diary made impossible. A schedule, rather than an aesthetic, put the piano on the record.²
The echo went to tape, not to the mix. Reverb from the echo chamber was recorded simultaneously in stereo across both tracks rather than only onto the vocal track, and the piano’s chamber return was captured in the overdub pass itself. Because it was on the tape, it went through the speed change with the instrument. Listen for it: the ambience around the piano figure is pitched and paced differently from the ambience around everything else, which is a thing you cannot do by turning up a send.²
Two engineers, one song. Norman Smith engineered the recording and the mixes; Stuart Eltham engineered the overdub in between. Eltham was George Martin’s regular balance engineer away from pop, and the 20 February date was a producer at a piano in an empty studio rather than a band session — closer to Martin’s comedy and orchestral work than to the album day nine days earlier. The Quick Facts row names Norman Smith because he carried the song from first take to final master; the exception is one morning in Studio One.^1,2
Geoff Emerick’s first Beatles session. Both primary sources put him in the room on 20 February 1963, as tape operator, and both flag it as his first appearance on a session by the group. He would be the balance engineer from Revolver onwards. The junior in the corner of an unattended overdub, watching a producer trick a piano into playing something nobody could play, is a reasonable place for that career to start.^1,2
How the album day was miked. For Please Please Me Norman Smith kept the microphones back and used no screens except the one around Paul’s bass cabinet, and even put up room mics to take in more of Studio Two’s ambience. After this album he moved toward closer miking to tighten the sound, though he went on working without screens. The openness is audible here — the drums carry room around them, and the band reads as four people in one space rather than four signals.²
Effects were otherwise almost absent. Across 1963 the application of effects was minimal and limited mainly to the studio’s echo chambers, with double-tracking becoming common only on the second LP and done by tape-to-tape superimposition. Against that background the half-speed piano is not a small flourish on a heavily treated record; it is very nearly the only processing decision on the album that could not have been made in 1962.²
The simultaneous Delta-Mono habit ended within weeks. Running a mono tape alongside the Twin-Track was a safety net: neither George Martin nor Norman Smith had experience recording rock and roll of this kind, and if the live mono balance failed they still had the Twin-Track to remix from. The practice was discontinued after the 13 March 1963 session for ‘Thank You Girl’, once it was clear that remixing from the Twin-Track was going to be the preferred method and the second tape was a waste of stock and time. ‘Misery’ sits just inside the window where both tapes ran.²
The idea came back for the middle eight of a film title. A year later, stuck for the middle-eight solo on ‘A Hard Day’s Night’, George Martin returned to the half-speed piano method he had used here — this time with the tape at 7.5 ips against the usual 15, and with Martin on piano and George on electric guitar playing the line together, an octave below the intended pitch, so that it came back at the right speed on playback. The doubling of piano and guitar is what gives that solo its unplaceable timbre, and the technique it rests on was invented to cover a part George could not play on this song.²

Releases

Every issued version descends from take 16, so what separates them is mixing, mastering and channel layout rather than performance.

1963 UK LP mono — Please Please Me (22 March 1963, Parlophone PMC 1202, side one, track two) — the mix of the period and the one to hear first. Everything sums to a single centred image, which suits the record: the half-speed piano sits inside the band rather than beside it, and its bright, fast-speaking attack registers as a strange edge on the arrangement instead of an obvious overdub. This mix is also edited — its instrumental introduction runs about one note, roughly a sixth of a second, shorter than every other version.
1963 UK LP stereo — Please Please Me (22 March 1963, Parlophone PCS 3042, side one, track two) — the two tape tracks thrown hard left and hard right with nothing in the middle. Backing occupies one side and voices the other, so the piano arrives in the same channel as the vocal it was overdubbed onto. The separation makes the overdub easy to study and harder to enjoy.
1963 UK EP mono — The Beatles (No 1) (1 November 1963, Parlophone GEP 8883, side A, track two) — the LP mono master on a four-track EP behind ‘I Saw Her Standing There’, cut louder for a seven-inch disc. No new mix; the interest is that the song was considered strong enough to sell an EP eight months after the album.
1964 US LP — Introducing… The Beatles (Vee-Jay VJLP 1062 mono / VJSR 1062 stereo) — the song’s first American home, the UK album having had no US release of its own until 1987. It carries a second mono mix made the same day as the British one, though whether Vee-Jay pressed that mix or simply folded the stereo down to mono cannot be settled by ear, since an unedited mono mix would sound the same either way.
1980 US LP — Rarities (Capitol SHAL 12060) — carries a rebalanced version of the 1963 stereo mix rather than the mix itself. The left-hand instrumental channel is brought up relative to the right, which softens the hard split, but reverb has also been added — most audibly on the opening vocal. It is the only materially different stereo image the song has ever had, and not an innocent one.
1987 CD — Please Please Me (EMI CDP 7 46435 2) — the first digital issue, and mono by design: the whole album was released on CD in mono on the grounds that the 1963 stereo was never the attended mix. This is also the point at which the UK album finally became the standard edition worldwide.
2009 stereo remaster — Please Please Me (Apple 82416 2) — the 1963 stereo mix with its panning untouched, in a cleaner transfer. More detail in the cymbals and in the tail of the piano figure, where the speed-shifted chamber return is now clearly separable from the room.
2009 mono remaster — the mono companion programme — the 1963 mono master remastered alongside the stereo series, and the recommended version of this track given how absolute the original channel split is.
2013 digital — Bootleg Recordings 1963 (Apple, download only) — takes 1 and 7 from the album day, in stereo, released to hold copyright. Take 1 shows guitar and drum parts that changed before the master, and take 7 still has the band attempting the guitar figure that the 20 February piano would eventually replace.

Sources

Mark Lewisohn, The Complete Beatles Recording Sessions (New York: Harmony Books, 1988), 8, 24, 28, 200.
Kevin Ryan and Brian Kehew, Recording the Beatles: The Studio Equipment and Techniques Used to Create Their Classic Albums (Houston: Curvebender Publishing, 2006), 362, 368–69, 381.

Frequently asked

Who wrote Misery?

John and Paul, for Helen Shapiro to record. She turned it down, and Kenny Lynch released it instead. The two of them also share the lead vocal on the Beatles’ own version.¹

Who sings lead on Misery?

John and Paul together.¹

When was Misery recorded?

11 February 1963, in the 2.30–6.00pm block of the Please Please Me album day, in Studio Two at EMI, Abbey Road. George Martin added the piano on 20 February in Studio One, and the mono and stereo masters were mixed on 25 February.¹

How many takes did Misery require?

Sixteen is the highest number on the sheet, but only eleven were cut with the band. Takes 12–16 are superimposition takes from the piano overdub nine days later, which the Beatles did not attend.¹

Why is the piano recorded at half speed?

Because George could not play the descending guitar figure smoothly. George Martin asked him to leave it out and had a take recorded with the Twin-Track machine running at 30 ips instead of the usual 15; at the overdub both machines ran at 15 ips, so he could play the line at half tempo and an octave down. Back at full speed it returns at the right pitch with a timbre a piano cannot produce in real time. It is the only track on the album made this way.²

Was this Geoff Emerick’s first Beatles session?

Yes — he was tape operator at the 20 February 1963 piano overdub, and both primary sources record it as his first appearance on a session by the group. Stuart Eltham engineered that date rather than Norman Smith.^1,2

Which version should I listen to?

The mono. The 1963 stereo puts the backing wholly in one channel and the voices wholly in the other, with nothing between them, so the piano lands in the same speaker as the vocal it was overdubbed onto. The mono sums it into one image and is the mix the record was made for.